England has clamped down on upfront rent. Could Wales be next?
Cross the border from Chepstow into Gloucestershire and the rules of renting a home have suddenly become rather different.
Since May, a landlord in England can no longer ask a prospective tenant to stump up six or 12 months of rent before handing over the keys. Rental bidding – where desperate tenants offer more than the advertised price to get ahead of the competition – has been banned too.
A few miles away in Wales, neither rule applies.
It is an unusual reversal for a country that was, not long ago, ahead of England on renters’ rights.
Wales overhauled its rental system in 2022, giving tenants longer notice periods and stronger protections over the condition of their homes while Westminster was still arguing over what to do with Section 21.
Four years later, England has caught up and, in some areas, overtaken it.
Now, with another renters’ rights bill on the Welsh Government’s agenda, the question is whether Wales will follow.
Six months’ rent can mean finding thousands before moving day
The difference over upfront rent sounds dry until you put a price on it.
The average private rent in Wales has reached £843 a month, according to the latest figures from the Office for National Statistics, up 4.5% in a year.
Six months at that price is £5,058. A full year is £10,116.
And £843 does not get you very far everywhere.
The average private rent in Cardiff is now well above £1,000 a month, while renters in parts of Wales have seen prices rise at more than twice the national rate. In Powys, average rents have climbed 9.7% in the space of a year.
For renters who sail through referencing, none of that necessarily means paying half a year’s rent at once. It tends to become an issue for those who don’t.
An international worker who has only recently arrived in Britain may have a salary but little UK credit history. A freelancer may earn enough over the course of a year but struggle to produce the tidy monthly payslips a referencing system expects. A student may have financial backing from parents overseas, but no UK homeowner willing to sign on the dotted line as guarantor.
For years, one answer has been: pay more upfront. In England, that escape route has now largely been closed. In Wales, it remains open.
England and Wales have quietly swapped places
Wales was once the obvious place to point to when arguing England’s rental laws were falling behind.
The Renting Homes (Wales) Act, which came fully into force in December 2022, replaced conventional tenancy agreements with occupation contracts and gave renters a minimum six months’ notice in many no-fault possession cases.
England still had Section 21. That changed this year. The Renters’ Rights Act has abolished Section 21 no-fault evictions in England, stopped landlords encouraging bidding above the advertised rent and changed the rules around large upfront payments.
Wales still allows landlords to regain possession without alleging fault through Section 173, subject to the rules around when and how notice can be served. There is no Welsh equivalent of England’s rental bidding ban either.
The result is something few renters are likely to think about when browsing Rightmove: the protections attached to a home can change depending on which side of the Severn or the Wye it happens to sit.
Paying upfront solved one problem by creating another
There is a reason landlords ask for guarantees. Handing a property worth hundreds of thousands of pounds to a stranger inevitably involves some assessment of whether the rent is going to arrive each month.
Where a tenant cannot pass the usual referencing process or produce a guarantor, a large upfront payment has offered an obvious alternative.
For some renters, it works perfectly well. For others, it creates a peculiar test of affordability.
Someone may earn enough to comfortably pay £900 every month, yet fail to secure a £900-a-month home because they do not have £5,400 sitting in their bank account.
Marco Laurence, CEO and founder of Rentmigo, which provides professional rent guarantor services, says the distinction is becoming increasingly important.
“Being able to afford your rent every month and having six or 12 months of rent sitting in cash are two completely different things,” he said.
“We speak to people with good jobs and perfectly reasonable budgets who hit a wall because they don’t have the right kind of guarantor. It happens a lot with people who’ve moved to the UK, but also with freelancers, contractors and people whose parents simply aren’t homeowners or aren’t in a position to guarantee their rent.
“Paying months upfront has often been the fallback. The trouble is that you’re then asking someone who has already passed an affordability check in real life – they know they can pay the rent each month – to suddenly find thousands of pounds before they can move.
“If Wales does decide to tighten the rules, it needs to make sure those renters aren’t squeezed out in a different way. Landlords still need security. The answer has to be giving them other ways to get it, rather than making the pool of tenants they’ll consider smaller.”
Wales is preparing another shake-up
The timing makes the gap with England harder to ignore. The Welsh Government has already put legislation to strengthen private renters’ rights on its programme for the new Senedd term, alongside plans aimed at housing affordability and further restrictions on no-fault evictions.
What ministers have not yet done is promise an English-style cap on upfront rent or a ban on rental bidding. That leaves plenty still to fight over.
Landlord groups are likely to argue that removing financial safeguards without addressing the risk behind them could make owners more selective about who they rent to. Tenant campaigners, meanwhile, can point to a system where access to a home can depend not just on whether somebody can afford the rent, but whether they happen to have thousands of pounds available on demand.
And all of this is happening in a rental market that is becoming more expensive. At £843 a month, the average Welsh renter is paying around £36 more each month than they were a year ago. That is more than £430 over 12 months without moving house, gaining another bedroom or getting anything extra for the money.
The next battle may happen before a tenant gets the keys
Much of the political argument about renting has traditionally focused on what happens after somebody moves in: how much their rent can rise, whether their home is fit to live in and how easily they can be evicted.
The next argument may be about whether they can get through the front door in the first place.
England has decided that asking renters to produce half a year’s rent, or allowing them to bid against one another for a home, has gone too far.
Wales has not – at least, not yet. That does not mean Cardiff Bay will copy Westminster. Housing is devolved precisely so Wales can write its own rules, and its rental system already looks markedly different from England’s.
But it does leave Welsh ministers with a slightly uncomfortable new comparison. For once, when it comes to some of the protections offered to private renters, Wales is the country doing the catching up.