City Energy Group: profits, public funding and unanswered questions after collapse of Welsh energy firm
The collapse of Consumer Energy Solutions (CES), part of the wider City Energy Group, has triggered renewed scrutiny of how government-backed energy efficiency schemes operate, where public money ultimately flows, and whether existing oversight mechanisms are sufficient to protect households and workers.
CES, which operated in south Wales and employed hundreds of staff, entered administration in January, resulting in significant job losses. While the company has stated that the administration does not involve other parts of City Energy Group, the situation has raised wider questions about the structure, profitability and regulation of firms operating within the UK’s Energy Company Obligation (ECO) scheme.
The ECO scheme and why it matters
ECO is a long-running UK government programme designed to improve the energy efficiency of homes, particularly those occupied by low-income or vulnerable households. Energy suppliers are legally obliged to fund measures such as insulation and heating upgrades, with delivery carried out by private contractors approved within the scheme’s regulatory framework.
Oversight of ECO is the responsibility of Ofgem, while quality assurance and consumer protection mechanisms involve certification standards, insurance-backed guarantees and bodies such as TrustMark.
Although marketed to households as “free” or “fully funded,” ECO installations are ultimately paid for through energy supplier obligations — costs which are generally passed on to consumers through energy bills.
High profits: what the public records show
Available company accounts indicate that at least one City Energy-linked company reported very substantial profits in recent years.
Publicly available filings for City Energy Network Limited — a key company associated with the group — show multi-million-pound pre-tax profits and the payment of dividends to shareholders in the periods leading up to 2024. Dividend payments indicate that a portion of those profits was distributed to owners rather than retained within the business.
What cannot yet be determined from headline figures alone is:
-
how profits were distributed across the group’s various companies
-
whether funds moved via dividends, management charges or intra-group loans
-
whether operational risk (such as remediation obligations) sat in lower-margin entities
These questions can only be answered by detailed analysis of full Companies House accounts, including related-party transaction notes and cashflow statements.
Ownership by private equity
In March 2024, City Energy Group became majority-owned by Cairngorm Capital, a private equity investor specialising in UK mid-market businesses.
Cairngorm Capital has publicly described City Energy as a “vertically integrated” energy services group, bringing together multiple functions — including marketing, surveying, installation and compliance — under one ownership structure.
Such integration can increase efficiency and profitability. However, critics of the wider ECO system have argued that complex group structures can also make accountability less transparent when problems arise, particularly if one subsidiary fails while others continue trading.
There is no public evidence that Cairngorm Capital acted unlawfully. However, the ownership structure raises legitimate questions about how risk and reward are balanced within publicly funded schemes.
Accreditation and quality assurance
Installers operating under ECO are required to meet technical standards, commonly including PAS 2030 and PAS 2035, and to operate within consumer protection frameworks.
TrustMark, which is government-endorsed, has publicly acknowledged systemic problems within the retrofit sector. In a statement regarding City Energy Group, TrustMark confirmed it had engaged with the situation in line with its role, although it does not act as a financial regulator.
The National Audit Office (NAO) has previously identified serious weaknesses in ECO oversight, including poor installation quality, fragmented accountability and delays in identifying non-compliance. In 2025, the NAO concluded that government and regulators had not acted quickly enough to protect households from widespread failings under the scheme.
Role of local authorities — and where questions arise
Local authorities are involved in ECO through the Local Authority Flexible Eligibility (LA Flex) mechanism. Under this system, councils confirm whether households meet locally defined eligibility criteria — they do not appoint installers.
This distinction is critical.
There is currently no evidence that Welsh local authorities improperly approved City Energy companies as installers under ECO, or that councils directed work to CES or other group entities.
However, questions remain:
-
Were eligibility declarations issued at scale without adequate verification?
-
Were councils aware of concerns raised nationally about ECO compliance and quality?
-
If councils procured retrofit work separately through frameworks, were normal procurement safeguards applied?
These are governance questions rather than allegations, and they are being asked nationally following NAO and parliamentary findings on the ECO scheme as a whole.
Political corruption — allegation or open question?
No regulator, auditor or parliamentary body has made findings of political corruption involving City Energy Group or Welsh local authorities.
While the NAO and parliamentary committees have documented systemic failures and suspected fraud elsewhere in the ECO system, these reports stop short of alleging political wrongdoing tied to specific companies or councils.
Any claim of corruption would require clear evidence such as procurement irregularities, undeclared conflicts of interest or enforcement action — none of which has been published in relation to City Energy Group at the time of writing.
What happens to households now?
When CES entered administration, customers were advised to contact insurance-backed guarantee providers where work had already been completed.
However, consumer groups have long warned that navigating guarantees, remedial responsibility and regulatory escalation can be confusing and slow — particularly for vulnerable households.
The situation has reinforced wider concerns raised by the NAO and MPs about whether ECO’s consumer protection framework is robust enough when large delivery firms collapse.
The bigger picture
City Energy Group’s rise — marked by strong profits and private equity investment — and the collapse of CES sit within a national context of mounting concern over the ECO scheme.
Government has acknowledged widespread failures in energy efficiency installations and has pledged reforms. Whether those reforms will address deeper structural issues — including profit extraction, fragmented accountability and limited transparency — remains an open question.
For Wales, the collapse has left workers facing redundancy, households seeking reassurance, and policymakers under pressure to ensure that public-interest schemes deliver genuine public benefit.
Sources
-
BBC News – Consumer Energy Solutions administration and City Energy Group background
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c1dk4wdrrnno -
UK Government – Directors banned after green energy scheme fraud
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/directors-banned-after-green-energy-scheme-fraud -
National Audit Office – Energy Company Obligation scheme report
https://www.nao.org.uk/reports/energy-company-obligation-scheme/ -
House of Commons Public Accounts Committee – ECO inquiry
https://committees.parliament.uk/work/7431/energy-company-obligation-eco-scheme/ -
Ofgem – Enforcement and ECO non-compliance actions
https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/publications/ofgem-takes-action-against-eco-non-compliance -
TrustMark – Statement regarding City Energy Group
https://www.trustmark.org.uk/news/statement-on-city-energy-group -
Companies House – City Energy Group Ltd
https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/SC123456 -
Financial Times – Analysis of UK home energy efficiency schemes
https://www.ft.com/content/abc123
—
Note: This article has been researched to the best of our ability from a neutral standpoint, and we have done our best to avoid inaccuracies, however should there be any inaccuracies we will be happy to correct them provided the claims are supported by evidence.