Senedd Debate Descends Into Farce As Politicians Struggle Not To Say ‘Blanket’
A debate about Wales’ controversial 20mph speed limits descended into something resembling a particularly unforgiving game of verbal charades after Senedd Members repeatedly found themselves in trouble for using the word “blanket”.
What was supposed to be a serious political debate about road safety, transport policy and the future of the 20mph default instead became, at times, a test of whether politicians could discuss the policy without accidentally saying the apparently dreaded B-word.
Several failed.
Even the Presiding Officer eventually described proceedings as “word bingo”.
The extraordinary exchanges came during a Reform UK-led debate on Wednesday, September 30, when Members were repeatedly reminded that describing the 20mph policy as a “blanket” restriction had previously been ruled inaccurate.
The reason is relatively straightforward.
Since September 2023, the default speed limit on restricted roads in Wales – generally residential and built-up roads with street lighting – has been 20mph rather than 30mph.
But it does not apply to every road. Councils can introduce exceptions and retain or restore 30mph limits where appropriate.
Consequently, describing the policy as “blanket” has previously been deemed inaccurate by the Senedd’s Standards of Conduct Committee.
Straightforward enough.
The difficulty, it transpired, was actually remembering not to say it.
‘I Apologise For Using The Word Blanket’
Welsh Conservative MS Janet Finch-Saunders was among those who discovered just how difficult navigating the linguistic minefield could be.
During her contribution, she referred to the “20mph default, blanket” before being interrupted by the Presiding Officer.
He reminded Members that there had already been a “very clear ruling” on the terminology.
Ms Finch-Saunders pointed out that she had used both “default” and “blanket”, but the Presiding Officer responded:
“Well, Janet, can I just make clear to you that the standards commissioner and others have ruled on this and that ‘blanket’ is not appropriate?”
Ms Finch-Saunders replied:
“I apologise for using the word ‘blanket’.”
That might have been the end of the matter.
Unfortunately, the forbidden word was apparently difficult to keep under wraps.
Later in the same contribution, Ms Finch-Saunders referred once again to a “blanket limit”.
Another intervention followed.
Realising what she had done, she quickly corrected herself:
“I apologise—default.”
By this stage, the debate about speed limits was beginning to acquire the atmosphere of a party game in which contestants lose points every time they accidentally say the obvious word.
It Wasn’t Just The Conservatives
The linguistic difficulties were not confined to one political party.
Green Party MS Paul Rock also reportedly found himself accidentally uttering the word before covering his mouth and apologising.
He said:
“Sorry. I do apologise. It’s in my notes. I didn’t mean to say it. It’s really hard when I didn’t realise!”
Members from Reform UK and Plaid Cymru were also reportedly pulled up over use of the terminology.
Eventually, the Presiding Officer himself summed up proceedings with the words:
“It’s word bingo.”
And, by that stage, it was difficult to disagree.
A debate concerning one of the most controversial transport policies introduced in Wales in recent years had temporarily become dominated by elected politicians attempting not to say a seven-letter word.
Why Is ‘Blanket’ Effectively Off Limits?
There is, however, a serious background to the increasingly comic exchanges.
The dispute dates back to complaints about politicians describing the 20mph policy as a “blanket” restriction.
In 2024, the Senedd’s Standards of Conduct Committee concluded that the description was “imprecise and inaccurate” because the legislation did not impose a 20mph limit on every road and councils had powers to introduce exceptions.
The matter subsequently became more serious when Conservative MS Natasha Asghar continued using the terminology despite being aware of the previous findings.
The Standards Committee concluded that she had breached the code of conduct and brought the Senedd into disrepute.
Then-Presiding Officer Elin Jones subsequently told Members in the Chamber:
“It is not correct to use it in that context in this Chamber any more.”
Politicians are therefore perfectly entitled to criticise the 20mph policy, demand its abolition, question its costs or argue about its effectiveness.
They just need to remember not to call it a blanket policy while doing so.
Judging by Wednesday’s proceedings, this is proving surprisingly challenging.
Serious Debate Lost Beneath The Word Games
Behind the comedy, there remains a substantial political argument.
Reform UK used the debate to call for the default 20mph limit to be scrapped, arguing that 20mph restrictions should instead be targeted at locations where they are necessary.
Supporters of the current system point out that it has never meant every road in Wales being reduced to 20mph.
Senedd Research has previously calculated that, following implementation, around 37% of the Welsh road network by length was subject to a 20mph limit, with 63% remaining at 30mph or above.
Those figures demonstrate why “blanket” is technically problematic.
Whether repeatedly policing the word during a political debate helps public understanding of the policy is another question entirely.
There is plenty for politicians to argue about: road safety, journey times, public support, enforcement, economic effects, council exemptions and whether the policy should survive in its present form.
Instead, for part of Wednesday’s proceedings at least, the Senedd found itself embroiled in the political equivalent of trying not to think about an elephant.
Except in this case, it was a blanket.
And whatever Members do, they mustn’t mention the blanket.